Free browser tool · zero cloud lock-in
Source-Note Builder
Capture literature notes with strict tripartite provenance separation: verbatim quote, paraphrase, and researcher inference.
Runs 100% locally in your browser. Capture academic and technical literature notes with strict tripartite provenance separation: verbatim quotations with page locators, faithful author paraphrases, and researcher inferences. Never fabricates missing metadata.
Step 1: Bibliographic Metadata
Enter source metadata. Missing authors or dates will stay explicitly unrecorded.
Step 2: Tripartite Excerpts (Quote vs Paraphrase vs Inference)
Enforce strict cognitive separation: verbatim quotes, faithful paraphrases, and your own synthetic inferences.
"If, as we confront some task, a part of the world functions as a process which, were it done in the head, we would have no hesitation in recognizing as part of the cognitive process, then that part of the world is (so we claim) part of the cognitive process."
Commentary: The parity principle: core foundational criterion for extended cognition.
Otto relies on his notebook in the exact same functional role that Inga relies on biological memory; the difference in physical storage medium is cognitively irrelevant.
Commentary: Thought experiment comparing Alzheimer patient Otto and biological memory Inga.
Local-first Markdown vaults with wikilinks are modern manifestations of Otto’s notebook. When latency drops to zero and search is local, the file system operates as functional extended memory.
Commentary: Links to internal vault note [[Local-First Knowledge Architecture]] and [[Cognitive Offloading Heuristics]].
Step 3: Standard Bibliographic Citations
Generated citation formats adhering to honest provenance guidelines without invented authors.
Step 4: Obsidian Literature Note Preview
Structured Markdown note ready to save directly into your Obsidian literature notes folder.
---
title: "The Extended Mind and External Artifacts in Cognition"
citekey: "clark1998extended"
source_medium: "journal-article"
authors:
- "Andy Clark"
- "David J. Chalmers"
year: 1998
doi: "10.1093/analys/58.1.7"
tags:
- source/literature-note
- source/journal-article
---
# The Extended Mind and External Artifacts in Cognition
> **Bibliographic Citation (APA 7):**
> Andy Clark, David J. Chalmers (1998). The Extended Mind and External Artifacts in Cognition. *Analysis*, pp. 7-19. https://doi.org/10.1093/analys/58.1.7
## Executive Summary & Core Claim
Argues for active externalism: cognitive processes can extend beyond the biological boundary of skin and skull into environmental artifacts (notebooks, computing devices).
## 1. Direct Quotations (Verbatim)
> "If, as we confront some task, a part of the world functions as a process which, were it done in the head, we would have no hesitation in recognizing as part of the cognitive process, then that part of the world is (so we claim) part of the cognitive process." (p. 8)
> — *Note:* The parity principle: core foundational criterion for extended cognition.
## 2. Paraphrase (Author Arguments in Researcher Words)
- **Paraphrase [pp. 12-14]:** Otto relies on his notebook in the exact same functional role that Inga relies on biological memory; the difference in physical storage medium is cognitively irrelevant.
- *Context:* Thought experiment comparing Alzheimer patient Otto and biological memory Inga.
## 3. Researcher Inferences & Vault Connections
- **Inference / Hypothesis:** Local-first Markdown vaults with wikilinks are modern manifestations of Otto’s notebook. When latency drops to zero and search is local, the file system operates as functional extended memory.
- *Vault Relation:* Links to internal vault note [[Local-First Knowledge Architecture]] and [[Cognitive Offloading Heuristics]].
## BibTeX Record
```bibtex
@article{clark1998extended,
title = {The Extended Mind and External Artifacts in Cognition},
author = {Andy Clark and David J. Chalmers},
year = {1998},
journal = {Analysis},
volume = {58},
number = {1},
pages = {7-19},
doi = {10.1093/analys/58.1.7},
}
```Architecting Rigorous Source Notes: Tripartite Provenance in Personal Knowledge Management
In modern scholarship, investigative journalism, legal analysis, and technical research, reading notes form the foundation of all subsequent synthesis. Yet standard digital note-taking frequently suffers from a severe epistemological vulnerability: the gradual degradation of provenance. When notes are taken hurriedly, verbatim quotations are stripped of page numbers, paraphrases subtly distort the author’s original intent, and the researcher’s own speculative reactions become inextricably entangled with empirical findings.
1. The Cognitive Hazard of Attribution Slippage and Cryptomnesia
Cognitive psychologists refer to unconscious plagiarism as cryptomnesia—the phenomenon where an idea or phrasing generated by an external source resurfaces in memory stripped of its origin, leading the researcher to believe it is their own original insight. Conversely, attribution slippage occurs when a researcher’s own analytical inference or reaction is later misremembered as a claim made by the original author.
When you return to a literature note six months after reading a paper, the memory of what was an exact quote versus what was your tentative reaction has faded. If your notes do not enforce structural partitioning between these modes of thought, you risk citing a source for a claim they never made, or committing inadvertent plagiarism in your final manuscript.
2. The Tripartite Provenance Separation Standard
To prevent attribution drift, rigorous research workflows demand a tripartite separation of every excerpt recorded from a source:
- Tier 1: Direct Quotations (Verbatim). Exact, letter-for-letter transcriptions of the source text. Verbatim quotes must always be enclosed in quotation marks and paired with an immutable locator—an exact page number (e.g.,
p. 8), paragraph index (e.g.,para. 4), or timestamp (e.g.,00:14:22). Verbatim quotes are immutable: you must never edit, paraphrase, or smooth out the author’s language within the quotation block. - Tier 2: Paraphrases (Author Claims in Researcher Words). A disciplined restatement of the author’s argument, evidence, or empirical findings expressed entirely in your own prose. The goal of a paraphrase is epistemic fidelity: it must accurately reflect the author’s meaning without introducing external value judgments or counter-arguments. Paraphrases still require locators so you can verify the underlying reasoning.
- Tier 3: Inferences & Commentary (Researcher Reactions & Vault Connections). Your own cognitive reactions to the material. This includes critiques of methodology, synthetic hypotheses, perceived contradictions with other literature, and bidirectional links (wikilinks) connecting this source to your permanent conceptual notes. Inferences are explicitly labeled as researcher-originated, ensuring they are never mistaken for author claims.
3. Why Missing Metadata Must Stay Missing
A widespread flaw in automated bibliographic extractors and AI note-taking tools is the fabrication or hallucination of missing metadata. When an archival manuscript lacks an author, poorly configured tools often label it "Anonymous" or guess an author based on unrelated file metadata. When an undated web document is imported, tools frequently insert today’s retrieval date as the publication date.
In scholarly citation systems (including APA 7th, Chicago 17th, and MLA 9th), fabricating metadata violates academic integrity. If an author is unrecorded, it must be acknowledged as unrecorded; if a publication date cannot be established, it must be designated n.d. (no date). This tool adheres strictly to honest provenance: missing fields are surfaced through explicit completeness warnings and preserved as unrecorded attributes in YAML frontmatter.
4. Integrating Literature Notes into Obsidian and Zettelkasten Vaults
In Niklas Luhmann’s Zettelkasten methodology, literature notes (Literaturzettel) serve as bibliographic anchors that precede the creation of permanent conceptual notes (Hauptzettel). A literature note is dedicated to a single external document. It should not be cluttered with unrelated musings, but should instead capture the core architecture of that specific work.
This tool structures literature notes for seamless integration into Obsidian, Logseq, and Pandoc Markdown ecosystems. The generated file includes standard YAML frontmatter containing the source citekey (e.g., clark1998extended), author arrays, publication year, and source medium tags. In the "Researcher Inferences" section, you can embed bidirectional wikilinks to relevant concept notes in your vault, creating a rich, traceable network of evidence.
5. Exporting Structured Excerpts for Systematic Reviews
For systematic literature reviews, scoping reviews, and meta-analyses, researchers must often compile excerpts across hundreds of papers into evidence synthesis tables. In addition to clean Markdown, this tool generates a formula-guarded CSV excerpts ledger containing every quote, paraphrase, and inference tagged with its locator, source title, and author. Every spreadsheet formula prefix (=, +, -, @) is safely escaped to prevent formula injection attacks when opening the audit ledger in spreadsheet applications.
6. Local-First Privacy and Academic Independence
Scholarly reading notes frequently encompass embargoed manuscripts, unpublished archival discoveries, sensitive investigative sources, and proprietary technical blueprints. This tool operates 100% locally in your browser memory. No text, citations, page numbers, or commentary are ever uploaded to cloud servers or third-party tracking services. Your intellectual inquiries remain private, sovereign, and entirely under your control.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions regarding academic source notes, tripartite provenance, and Markdown integration.
Questions
What is a source note (literature note) in personal knowledge management?
A source note (or literature note in Zettelkasten terminology) is a dedicated record capturing insights from a specific external work—such as an academic paper, book, report, or interview. Its purpose is to record what the author actually argued, separate from your own synthetic ideas, before you create permanent conceptual notes.
Why does this tool enforce strict tripartite provenance separation?
Researchers frequently commit unintentional cryptomnesia or attribution slippage by blending an author’s exact words with personal interpretations. By strictly separating direct verbatim quotations, faithful paraphrases, and subjective inferences into distinct sections, you eliminate the risk of misattributing your own ideas to the source or quoting out of context.
How does the tool handle missing authors or publication dates?
Under strict scholarly provenance rules, missing metadata must stay missing rather than being fabricated. If an author is unspecified, the tool formats the citation as [Author unrecorded] and warns you; if the date is missing, it formats as n.d. (no date). The tool never invents contemporary dates or placeholder authors.
Can this tool generate BibTeX citation keys for reference managers?
Yes. It generates standard deterministic citation keys combining the first author’s last name, publication year, and the first meaningful title word (e.g., clark1998extended). It also generates a complete BibTeX entry ready for Zotero, JabRef, or Pandoc bibliographies.
How do source notes connect to permanent conceptual notes in Obsidian?
The generated Markdown note includes YAML frontmatter tags, citekeys, and a dedicated "Researcher Inferences & Vault Connections" section. In this section, you link concepts to your evergreen notes using standard Obsidian wikilinks ([[Concept Note]]), grounding your synthetic claims in verifiable literature.
Does this tool transmit my reading notes or manuscripts over the internet?
No. This utility executes 100% in local browser memory. No text, citations, page locators, or excerpts leave your device.
Keep your notes private, portable, and fast
Write your daily records in clean, future-proof plain Markdown on your local disk with zero cloud lock-in.